Panoramio is closing. Learn how to back up your data.

sms

Selected for Google Maps and Google Earth

Comments (14)

逃离城市 on September 7, 2008

Interesting. Why doesn't know, I thought can understand such photography mental state. The instant feeling is remembered. Yes?

These hand fingerprint has formed one behavior art. Truly very art. Has the red window frame especially.

flees

Malko - VIEWS, NO TH… on September 7, 2008

Art? well... I don't know, but when I saw this door I knew I must to take the photo.

Greetings.

逃离城市 on September 7, 2008

I said am behavior art.Why otherwise do you want to photograph? en```does not talk clearly, I can understand.

逃离城市 on September 8, 2008

Sorry, Malko,I want to explain behavior art is any, because does not want to let you think does not have the basis to this picture praise.:)

Behavior art has very many kinds, very many is the behavior which some artistic own define, makes an effect .but I do not like that kind of art.

Also some one kind is natural, was people (even is animal)consciousness actually has not made a result, made the impression to the human the thing .They may not duplicate, also possibly the very short time can vanish.(For instance ground stays behind some very attractive wheel rut)

Cites an example, you understand.This Olympic Games opening ceremony that drawing paper you have seen? After it spreads the picture, the hand the process, Finally places ground, is passed through by more than 20,000 various countries' athletes in above, stays behind more than 20,000 double footprints in above.Finally this drawing paper was called in the world is retained for the greatest behavior art.Because it cannot duplicate, also not impossible to be imitated. You did not think that is the extraordinary art?

Above did not know said, can explain some questions to your this picture? Hoped me to talk clearly the idea.(If can use Chinese speech to be good) you to see after these, have please given a reply, I can delete these writing.

thank you,Regards.

Malko - VIEWS, NO TH… on September 9, 2008

Hello flees. My english is very short. So, it's difficult to me to explain my own point of view. But I will try it.

I don't think that all the "beautiful" or "interesting" things that men in action create (or the time passing by) must be called art or "behaviour art"

I think that "behavior art" needs an intentioned guy: someone who wish to create art.

What I want to say is that:

1- The door that you can see in my pic, just in his own "environment" is not art: people who wrote in the glass had not intention (I suppose) to create something like art.

2- If I were an artist (someone qualified for art) and if I were inspired, this pic could be art: this was my intention when I shot the photo. (It wouldn't be behavior art, anyway).

3- If someone had the idea to invite the people in the street to write in the door in order to create an artistic performance it could be considered like a "behavour art". The stadium footprints that you said may be art, but the footprints you can see in a beach (although can be nice) is not art.

Intention + capabilities + inspiration= art

Intention + random + luck maybe behavior art

Many thanks for your words. There is not usual that people lose his time writing more than just 5 or 6 words. And I really apreciate your effort.

(anyway, please don't delete your message. I think it's an interesting conversation, don't you?)

逃离城市 on September 9, 2008

Malko,Your English have been more than me, I looked completely had understood your meaning, said extremely clearly.

But, I have the different opinion. Perhaps is my language expression is not clear, I thought we have some small misunderstanding to the“ behavior art” understanding.But I hoped we do not limit in the words and expressions definition,ok? This is unimportant.

Our difference focal point in: Is that picture behavior art? Looked at your opinion, I thought I and you in this question basic are consistent.

First must be clear, I said art, is not these hand fingerprint, but is your picture, according to yours viewpoint:

Intention (hope creation art person, you not right?)+ Ability (photography technology, you do not have?)+ inspiration (comes from these hand fingerprint) = art

Intention + random (these hand fingerprint) + the luck (just to see them by you) possible behavior art

I to you looked a picture, the friend of mine photography, the wheel rut , further explains my viewpoint.I thought this picture is very good, unusual art, although it comes from an extremely ordinary ground, moreover never existed.You did not think this is an art? Certainly is not all wheel ruts all is art.Your artistic inference formula I agreed.

http://www.panoramio.com/photo/10922221

Moreover I want to say that, I to art the understanding, every the beautiful thing all am the art, including vision and spirit.Especially that kind real, natural. Beijing has several time behavior art display, nearly all is that kind specious work, revolting.I cannot worship blindly any artist, no matter he has any qualifications, If his work does not like, cannot say him well.

Hopes my speech not to let you not be happy.I thought two did not speak English the human uses English pk in here, very interesting. We do not have the big difference, this is I feels gratified.

Regards.Flees the city

Malko - VIEWS, NO TH… on September 10, 2008

You're right, ftc. We're agree in the fundamental ideas about art/not art. Thank you again for your time and expounds. Meet you in another pic ;)

逃离城市 on September 11, 2008

Such discussion takes to me joyful and the information. ^_^ Thanks you. ftc

Laurapamplo on February 22, 2010

Hi everybody, I want to tell you something. this window is from my village, Huarte and my friend and me have done the letters and draws.. if you considerate it art, thanks, I am a real artist ;)

Malko - VIEWS, NO TH… on February 22, 2010

Hola Laura.

Leo Izaskun(ika), Iranzu, Pili(ka), Alazne... ¿dónde estás tú, que no te veo? Espero que ya te hayas lavado el dedo, :D

No quiero desilusionarte, jejeje, pero en la conversación con 逃离城市 yo pretendía sostener que no se trataba de arte, pues no había intención artística tras los garabatos (¿la había?). Pero en cierto modo cumplió su misión, pues me provocó fijarme en la estampa y tirarle esta foto.

Gracias por comentarla.

Saludos.

Anonymous, on June 10, 2010, said:
The author of this comment has been deleted.
Malko - VIEWS, NO TH… on June 10, 2010

Se trata de la puerta de alguna cochera o taller fuera de uso, no recuerdo. A ver si paso otro día y te dejo un mensaje :D

Muchas gracias. Bss.

Anonymous, on May 17, 2013, said:
The author of this comment has been deleted.
Malko - VIEWS, NO TH… on May 17, 2013

Mmmmm.... si. Creo que te lo debo. A ver si paso otro día y te dejo un mensaje

Sign in to comment.

Photo details

  • Uploaded on September 6, 2008
  • © All Rights Reserved
    by Malko - VIEWS, NO TH…
    • Camera: Canon EOS 40D
    • Taken on 2008/08/30 12:09:09
    • Exposure: 0.008s (1/125)
    • Focal Length: 24.00mm
    • F/Stop: f/4.000
    • ISO Speed: ISO100
    • Exposure Bias: 0.00 EV
    • No flash

Groups